Over on the Spectacle Blog, Parker Peeveyhouse links to an article on a high school student who is running a banned-books library out of his locker...and kids are becoming readers because of it! This is a stick in the eye for those who want to ban the books, because saying 'don't read that' automatically ups the curiosity factor in the kids! (Nya nya you bigoted sourpusses!) What really got me, though, was the sorts of books on the banned list. Even this partial list was a shocker! They banned the Qu'ran, Canterbury Tales, Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy, His Dark Materials, Sabriel, Divine Comedy, and other books that are wonderful, many of which are staples in the humanities classes I took in high school, and which these kids will be seeing in college courses too.
And the main factor appears to be, once again, religious intolerance. As in, you must believe exactly as I do, and I'll ensure that by giving you nothing to change your mind. Which, as anyone who has studied any history at all knows, will not work. In fact, suppression of ideas tends to have the opposite effect than the one desired!
I am continually surprised at the narrowness of the minds of people. Good, well-meaning and church-going people who believe they are following the Word of their Lord by doing narrow-minded, cruel, bigoted things that can actually be contrary to what their holy works say. Things like deciding who can marry is a big example--or who can live, which a major point in the Middle East; but what I am talking about now is the restriction of knowledge itself, the thing that can broaden the minds of the young, our world's future, and maybe resolve some of the global problems we're having...instead of escalating them.
We have all heard the outcries against so many books lately. A Newberry Award winning book blasted for having the word 'scrotum' in it (The Higher Power of Lucky). Classics that have long been accepted suddenly becoming too hot to handle and banned in school libraries (Lolita, Catcher In The Rye, and recently a furor over Farenheit 451) and some newer works that threaten certain people's sensibilities. A good many of them appear to be speculative fiction, as well.
But the lists are growing and appear to be arbitrary. First a furor over Harry Potter. (Holy crap! Children might become Satanists if they read these books!) Instead, these seven tomes have brought a new generation of readers to the libraries.
Then there are the protests against Phillip Pullman's His Dark Materials books. The man's an athiest and he has a senile god who has abandoned the world. Instead of Pullman's fictional god being a villian, as some seem to think he is portraying the diety as, people are suffering because Pullman's villian is the church itself, not god, and the problems are caused by a lack of god's presence in the church! And that's what has people upset. (Oh, boo! A fictional church is evil! Could you be paranoid for a reason, peeps?) (And do you notice that not everyone can agree on which point is the objectionable one? God is portrayed as senile=bad; a church is portrayed as not being one with god's will=bad.) Pullman states his feelings on the matter here far better than I could.
In any case, the people who cry and scream when they are offended by a book are not the real problem. It is the overly-PC nature of the schools and library officials who decide to pull any book which offends one person's sensibilities. Which is censorship, which is failing to serve the public by providing materials for them to read and thus use to form their own opinions on things, perhaps even develop a slight ability for empathy, for seeing someone else's point of view. I mean, heaven forbid (she says ironically) we raise up children who are able to look at both sides of an issue and evaluate their response!
What is it that makes so many folks afraid that someone disagreeing with their take on life, god or whatever as dangerous? Why are they so afraid that their children will, by one exposure to something not of their parents' beliefs, become some heretic? Are they that insecure in how they raise their children? Or is it that they question themselves? If their faith is strong enough it should be able to handle a book or two that is not perfectly in line with their world view.
Rant over. Whew.
For more information on book bannings, check out Banned Books.
Recent Comments